Mizore - No, I don't. I don't have much extra cash floating around, as a grad student; I also don't have the knowledge or reach to get that money to people who need it most. How many charities do you know of who can support families during stressed times - not just provide a meal or a room for a night? The reason we have federal welfare is because the free markets and the states completely failed millions of Americans during the Great Depression. That is what unregulated markets do - they bubble and crash - so the times when the most people need help are precisely the times when charities are most strapped for cash.
KoD - It really depends on where you live. If you're Hawaiian, then you could make $36,000 a year on Welfare. On the other hand, if you live in Mississippi, you'd have to scrape by on ~$11,000 a year. Most states are on the lower end of that spectrum. Oh, I almost forgot the kicker: this is for a mother with two kids, who ALSO happens to qualify for every extra benefit possible. Do you think you and your two kids would be living in luxury on $1000/month?
I find it strange that I keep hearing the same two criticisms of Obama: 1. Unemployment is too high. 2. Obama's welfare state is discouraging everyone from wanting to work.
But these don't really mesh well, because unemployment rates only count people who are looking for work. If everyone's content to get their checks from the government, why are they looking for jobs?
- Welfare in some (about 1/3) states is too high. It could definitely discourage job seeking, especially if the person has low standards, anyway.
- Welfare recipients cannot stay on the federal TANF program for longer than 2 years without finding a job.
- Welfare is not luxurious, even in the highest-paying states.
- Federal welfare can't be diminished without tremendous backlash. The problem is that it really SHOULD be, or else the US government will eventually be on Chinese food stamps.
- Welfare functions as it should for most people on it: as a temporary safety net that can prevent homelessness until a new job can be found.
- Fewer than 5% of Americans are on welfare - that's not even 1/3 of people below the poverty rate. I didn't realize it was that low.
(By the way, thank you for bringing this up, because it was a great excuse to learn more about how our welfare system currently works. I found some things that I would change, but it's actually more restricted than I thought.)