Simcountry
Forum Help Defense question (Kebir Blue)

Defense question (Kebir Blue)

J
john Black (Kebir Blue)
15 Feb 2010 20:38 Link
So i understand that having weapons and ammunition in base stock as opposed to in units lowers ur DI and that garrisoning weapons and ammo in fortifications increases ur DI, what i dont get is the difference between having a defensive unit stationed and active at a base vs a garrison in a fortification, im assuming the troops are taken from the unit? or are these two seperate things? Im sure this has been asked but I havent had much luck finding the forums for this question
P
Plato (Little Upsilon)
15 Feb 2010 22:57 Link
The defense in SC lacks all coordination, so a unit located at a base will not help defend a base. Hence, the base needs a separate garrisons.
B
Blue Serpent (Little Upsilon)
15 Feb 2010 23:16 Link
not entirely true, a defensive unit placed next to a location will help that location to defend.
L
Luonnotar (Little Upsilon)
19 Feb 2010 02:09 Link
It will? Really?
P
Plato (Little Upsilon)
19 Feb 2010 22:50 Link
In my wars, I have never to my knowledge had a defensive unit, that wasn't being attacked, support another unit.

Forts apparently have an intrinsic garrison that responds in some way, when the defense at a Fort is attacked, but without a garrison that you put in it never damages the attacker. You just the get that irritating message about the the attack would have been lessened had there been MI in place.

No, defensive units just sit pleasantly awaiting annihilation.
D
Dr.Anthrax (Little Upsilon)
19 Feb 2010 23:04 Link
He could be talking about air defense units.
N
Noproblem (Fearless Blue)
20 Apr 2011 18:07 Link
Rather than start a new thread, I will us this one.
My question is :
Does quality in forts make any difference. I have never seen this discussed anywhere.
C
Crafty (Golden Rainbow)
20 Apr 2011 21:24 Link
My understanding, but by no means guaranteed 100% accurate.

I think that if there is no defensive garrison for the adjacent defensive unit to assist then it wont do much, however, an active defensive unit will assist a targets garrison provided it has suitable weapons. Kind of like offensive units support air attacks.
This is second hand information passed down from a very experienced war player of many many years.

Cant answer fort question but I would doubt Q is a factor yet, only weapons and ammo.
N
Noproblem
21 Apr 2011 06:23 Link
I would tend to agree that fort quality doesn't matter. Yet. What about it, Tommi ?

Thanks, Crafty