Well the community needs to be larger for a number of reasons, primary being so the game drama can be more fun and less personalized.
A large community can 'absorb' more, as it were.
With regard to the article Tuco posted, there are far too many "scrubs" playing, and players like myself either have to invent conflict or look for other ways to keep occupied.
I honestly don't know if this game would be any good at a high level because not enough people play it at a really high level. My intuition says the high levels will turn out to be more or the same, yet some things in my most recent war showed a bit of promise.
And Laguna, the very fact that you can be "ashamed" of "us people" means there are too few people playing. I could count off the number of active players who have left in my time and then compare it to the ones who have joined and remained active. As great as some of the newer people are, there really is no comparison and perhaps a few stack up, such as Dubthaigh, Ela, and Dac. EO is in the running also if he keeps playing.
However, we've lost (or de-facto in some cases), Ambiorix, Bayar, Scottie, Manny, Enigma, Ameche, Brince, Saber, Vicious, Purity, Veritas, Treasurer, David Walker (?), DGoE, Pink Floyd -
and that's just a sample of the ones who had a forum presence of some kind.
If you recall, there was plenty of healthy conflict... SFO versus NSA... the PPW/PPWU thing. It was fun, but got absorbed by the greater community. But I think even then we had about the minimum required to sustain a "bright, competitive, challenging game."
My recent actions, partially as the result of boredom and a desire to leave the game with a bang (I've found renewed stamina thanks to the players in EO's group who are very bright and could all replace the mentioned players above eventually), were also intended to inspire some life into LU.
SNA failed with its leadership left and the buckled to jason and I's test over Pathetic Sheep. Then Valde failed to do anything over it as well. SNA was attacked and destroyed, but it seems some good as come of it, as a new fed has joined LU and the active SNA people have all joined it. This makes for a stronger and better LU than had SNA been allowed to rot. Granted, it would have been more fun to see a new SNA join together to meet the threat and rise from the ashes.
At this note, I'd like to mention to Houston that I'm sorry for nuking him. I thought more people would care. Apparently, no one did. You can get mad at me (justifiably), or ask what's wrong with the active players on LU that no one cared enough to do anything about it. Times were a mere hostile bid would bring hell's fury on LU.
Valde was going to be next, to see if I could inspire some white knights, but thanks to Kevin and you, Laguna, I had an excuse in the form of defending EO. Btw, really shitty how you guys tried to maneuver with Chuck Steak. Just say you don't like the inactive raiding and declare. Then have a face-off and resolve it. But I couldn't let EO sit out there alone, and besides I had an invasion of VB all planned out anyways. It's actually good for Valde that you guys declared on EO because it pushed my timetable ahead.
Yet no one impressed me and no one impressive emerged. All that happened was Valde lost four countries, EO lost one country, and I used a ton of drones and oa2a up. It was nice to see dub roar, but he declared unprepared, suffered the consequences, and I was in the end disappointed in his reaction to it all.
What probably saved LU was the war engine freezing - for whatever reason, the GMs have no emailed me back about it. Oceanus would have fallen (not too big a feat considering it was 6 on 1), and unless Laguna or Kev came out of WP and actually mounted a response, it would have been on to Sir Michael next who I would have gutted like a fish. Michael: You have been temping and tasty swag for a long time. Buy some defense already. Then Martok: again, buy defense, and so on, until the only players left on LU were the ones in WP. I have maps. Ask EO.
However, it became apparent that there was no one to rise to the occasion, as I took time to reflect during the "break" in the war engine, and that being the case, if Laguna was going to be occupied until July there was no one who would be able to stop me. I find little pleasure in pwning players for the hell of it, and killing LU without a fight is indeed poor form.
I'm not going to pretend like this whole time I've been trying to be the secret savior of the game. I've been trying to raise some hell, but the lack of hell actually raised - because of lack of any real response, speaks to a deep disappointment. You should be more disappointed in the players who sit around watching their corps, counting their sim dollars, and feeling proud that their 1's and 0's are growing in a dutch computer, rather than the few players actually doing something to keep vitality in the game.
I picked the moniker Siva for this because Siva is the hindu god of destruction, but it is the destruction that precedes creation. In some rites, Siva is a sustained god, because through Siva, be destroying, allows things to be created again anew.